News:

BEFORE POSTING read our Guidelines.

Main Menu

Hakon Borresen

Started by JimL, Thursday 15 March 2012, 00:46

Previous topic - Next topic

Alan Howe



Ilja

It's interesting how both this symphony (1925) and Myaskovsky's 6th (1923) use the French revolutionary song Ah! ça ira in their finale. Perhaps that's understandable shortly after a revolution in Russian that mirrored itself so closely after the French, but from a Russian that might be more expected than from a Dane.

eschiss1

I don't understand your question. Many people in 1925 outside of the Soviet Union were hopeful of the USSR's prospects, as is, afaik, clear from any amount of writing by people from that time (and not all of it, as I recall, from Communists either- though I'm not sure we know Børresen's politics?) Anyway, good catch.

Ilja

Of course you're right, but Børresen is a somewhat unlikely suspect to have much sympathy for the communist cause, being a staunchly bourgeois part of the royal orchestra and royal theatre mileu in the Danish capital. Musically, he stayed well away from the contemporary avant-garde as well.

Justin

Quote from: Ilja on Tuesday 09 June 2026, 21:02Musically, he stayed well away from the contemporary avant-garde as well.

Regardless of one's political inclinations, this is a wise move in my book!

eschiss1

Still amazes me that we can call anything written one hundred years ago "avant-garde", fgs... and if we mean "compared to the rest of the stuff written at that time", ok, interesting.

Ilja

Solid point. Let's not forget that anything within a mile of Wagner was once regarded as dangerously subversive.

Justin

Perhaps atonal is a better word than avant-garde.

eschiss1

Already have gone way offtopic, and very few composers have ever written atonal music. (That you don't care for the composers of certain music, or the music, which has been described that way- generally by journalists with journalists' usual tremendous accuracy!- is certainly your right!)