Enescu's 5th symphony (completed by P.Bentoiu) + Isis
Deutsche Radio Philharmonie
conducted by Peter Ruzicka
Marius Vlad, Tenor
Thomas Bauer, Bariton
NDR Chor
quasi live broadcast (with a time shift of 1 hour) from a forthcoming Matinée concert in Saarbrücken / Germany
17.06.2012 | SR2 | 12:00
Hi, I recorded tonight's concert. I will edit and upload them ;)
If you uploaded this (I see you did, Jun 17 2012), please reconsider (well, ok, probably no longer exists in the new scheme of things anyway but) - this is now a recording on the cpo label (just announced as a new release, anyway, coupled together).
Source of this information, olease?
Hi Mike,
Here's the link:
http://www.jpc.de/jpcng/cpo/detail/-/art/george-enescu-symphonie-nr-5-fuer-tenor-frauenchor-orchester/hnum/3097665 (http://www.jpc.de/jpcng/cpo/detail/-/art/george-enescu-symphonie-nr-5-fuer-tenor-frauenchor-orchester/hnum/3097665)
Oh- sorry, yes, got it directly from the new releases section of JPC.de.
Thanks Alan abd Eric. Now, if only CPO would give catalogue numbers on their webpage....!
btw, cpo/jpc have a point- while these two works have been broadcast a fair deal if one's been fortunate enough to hear them that way (assuming they're one's cup of tea in the first place, as they are mine- the 5th symphony with its impressive funeral march especially) - this is, I think, the commercial recording premiere, after 20 years (from the time of reconstruction-from-sketches). (Of course that's rather less than some works have waited, my only point I guess, slight as it was, was that for some reason I'd managed to assume they'd been recorded even as much as a few times already, maybe subconsciously just because I do know I've heard a few different broadcast recordings of both (the symphony and Isis, I think) already (at least the ones that were on BBC a few years ago and the more recent ones from the Enescu Festival a couple of years back...) ;) )
Does anyone know of any plans to record the reconstructed 4th Symphony?
It was also reconstructed by Pascal Bentoiu, in 1996, and was recorded in the Mihail Hall of the Romanian Radio Society, 6th September 2011. It was played by the Transilvania State Philharmonic - Cluj and was available on YouTube at the time. It's in three movements but I have no further information except that it's 30 minutes in length. Can upload if it's no longer available.
I think he meant _commercially_ record, given the context (since I referred to a commercial recording of the 5th symphony and indeed there I think is an upload of the 4th and 5th symphony on our site (and the other symphonies, except no.2) - though one of the uploads of the 5th symphony (& Isis) should probably be removed in light of this cpo announcement, per our rules, I believe), but maybe not?...
Thanks, Eric. Yes, I meant "commercially" recorded. Sorry. I should have been clearer.
According to a comment on someone's YouTube (from 2 years ago, which I just noticed), there -is- or was a recording of the 4th and 5th symphonies on the label Editura, conducted by Andreescu. Ah. Ok!...
... which are presumably the same as these OOP Olympia releases...
http://www.allmusic.com/album/enescu-complete-orchestral-works-vol-1-mw0001815769 (http://www.allmusic.com/album/enescu-complete-orchestral-works-vol-1-mw0001815769)
http://www.allmusic.com/album/enescu-complete-orchestral-works-vol-6-mw0001823618 (http://www.allmusic.com/album/enescu-complete-orchestral-works-vol-6-mw0001823618) ....
Those links are to recordings which include performances of two of the four 'Study Symphonies' which predate Enescu's official Symphony No.1.
According to Mike Herman's discography, they were recorded on the album Editura Casa Radio 090, recorded 1998, released 2003. The two study symphony recordings were released in 1996, so they're of course not the same!
So, Eric, are you saying that the version I downloaded from UC (Romanian radio, live concert 7th Sept. 2011) is not a commercial recording? Sorry, but I had difficulty following the argument..... ::)
there've been two recordings- the Editura and the cpo recording. Allmusic claims that the cpo CD was recorded in June 2012. So I'm guessing that by our rules that since the live concert wasn't just a preparatory concert before the studio recording, or suchlike (which as I recall has also been sometimes been ruled inadmissable, I think... not sure... :) ) - well- I was mistaken, and apologize for the error and for this thread :(
No need to apologize, Eric - best to get these matters sorted as best we can. ;)