Unsung Composers

The Music => Composers & Music => Topic started by: GoranTch on Tuesday 27 May 2025, 16:56

Title: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: GoranTch on Tuesday 27 May 2025, 16:56
That the name of Felix Draeseke will be widely known among the members of this forum is, I believe, a reasonable assumption. And most likely the same assumption can be made about his most prominent works, not the least among which is his Symphony No.3, "Tragica".

But what about Symphonies Nos.1, 2 and 4? I myself have known his Nos. 1 and 2 for almost 15 years now, and every time I return to them, I end up being in disbelief that music of that kind of depth and compositional substance, of that level of beauty and craftmanship can be so utterly absent from our concert programs. I am not aware that there exists even a small Draeseke festival of some kind that would at least once in a year (or two years) perform a selection of his major works.

Did anybody here ever have the opportunity to hear his Nos. 1 and 2 in concert? And in general, what is your opinion of these works?
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Tuesday 27 May 2025, 17:25
I share your astonishment and your frustration. Unfortunately, despite the existence of excellent recordings, Draeseke's music is rarely performed in public, which is an absolute scandal. However, you may find this website useful: https://www.draeseke.org/



Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: eschiss1 on Tuesday 27 May 2025, 19:40
There was a song recital with some of his songs in Coburg this past January, but that's the exception, not the rule...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Tuesday 27 May 2025, 20:17
Thanks for that confirmation, Eric - sad though it is.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: eschiss1 on Wednesday 28 May 2025, 00:16
Well, I should say that I saw one announced, I don't know that it happened. Also, is this a CD or something being announced for 21 June? Event of Draeseke Lieder (https://www.coburgmarketing.de/event/lieder-von-draeseke) (CoburgMarketing.de) ...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: John Boyer on Wednesday 28 May 2025, 00:39
It's just the concert announcement, with the usual location, performers, date, and time, and also a duration.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Wednesday 28 May 2025, 10:17
Quite an important venture with regard to the composer's Lieder, but it'd be good to know of any performances of his orchestral music.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: eschiss1 on Wednesday 28 May 2025, 14:49
Not a symphony, but an orchestral work, the Gudrun Overture, to be performed in Coburg this season: this (https://www.landestheater-coburg.de/stuecke/konzert/1-sinfoniekonzert-zueignung/). (The Coburg orchestra has some interesting programming, even including Bacewicz violin concertos and thelike...- so does the Wuppertal orchestra with which Hanson recorded the symphonies, now that I look at that, too! Good orchestras both, apparently.)
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Wednesday 28 May 2025, 17:09
Thanks, Eric. Very much better than nothing!
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: GoranTch on Wednesday 28 May 2025, 18:35
Quote from: Alan Howe on Tuesday 27 May 2025, 17:25I share your astonishment and your frustration. Unfortunately, despite the existence of excellent recordings, Draeseke's music is rarely performed in public, which is an absolute scandal. However, you may find this website useful: https://www.draeseke.org/





Thank you for the link. I see you are based in England - did you ever have an opportunity to hear a Draeseke symphony in concert there (or in Britain in general)?
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: GoranTch on Wednesday 28 May 2025, 18:42
Quote from: eschiss1 on Wednesday 28 May 2025, 14:49Not a symphony, but an orchestral work, the Gudrun Overture, to be performed in Coburg this season: this (https://www.landestheater-coburg.de/stuecke/konzert/1-sinfoniekonzert-zueignung/). (The Coburg orchestra has some interesting programming, even including Bacewicz violin concertos and thelike...- so does the Wuppertal orchestra with which Hanson recorded the symphonies, now that I look at that, too! Good orchestras both, apparently.)

Astonishing. This is the first time I have actually seen a major orchestral work by Draeseke on a concert program in Germany, and I have been living in Berlin for the last 20 years. Probably only happened due to Coburg being the town of his birth.

How does the East of US fare in performing Draeseke's orchestral music? Did you ever have the opportunity to hear his symphonies (or even just overtures) in concert in New York, Boston or any other major city (relatively) nearby? 

Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: eschiss1 on Thursday 29 May 2025, 01:06
I haven't. I'm not aware even of any orchestral performances or chamber performances of Draeseke's music in the Eastern US since the 19th century, except for a few of his piano pieces at Bard University in the 2000s.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Thursday 29 May 2025, 09:47
Quote from: GoranTch on Wednesday 28 May 2025, 18:35in England - did you ever have an opportunity to hear a Draeseke symphony in concert there (or in Britain in general)?

No, never.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: eschiss1 on Thursday 29 May 2025, 13:05
His Jubilee (Jubel-) Overture Op.65 was at the Proms once, but I doubt any of us was alive back on 7 September 1905! (It's not ultra-clear from the website whether Wood or Verbruggen conducted it; research might elucidate :) )
(And when the opening of the Classicstoday article is "Felix Draeseke is best known for his monumentally long (and dull) oratorio Christus", I think some work really needs to be done. The new recordings of the string quartets are a good start-- but a new recording of, e.g., the cello sonata on a label with more than nominal distribution -- or many -more- recordings of it (why should so many wonderful currently-unknown works receive one recording, revealing only one aspect, each?) - would help. (I don't think it helps that Wollenweber charges an arm and a leg for critical editions, but recordings based on the first editions would hardly be horrible. This would leave out works like the lovely A major Stelzner-quintet for which the two are the same and the Wollenweber parts cost $110 or so, discouraging performance, but.))
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: FBerwald on Thursday 29 May 2025, 17:15
I'm waiting for the day when we will finally get to hear the orchestrated version of his Violin concerto.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Thursday 29 May 2025, 17:18
Quote from: FBerwald on Thursday 29 May 2025, 17:15I'm waiting for the day when we will finally get to hear the orchestrated version of his Violin concerto.
Me too. I have the score, but I can't interest anyone in a performance...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Gareth Vaughan on Thursday 29 May 2025, 17:27
Oh, me too. It's a gorgeous work.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: eschiss1 on Friday 30 May 2025, 01:43
BTW Operabase seems to be a good website for finding some performance information past and present (edit: except for the fact that after a few uses, they expect one to subscribe at levels like 1500 pounds, so, not in my budget.) They list a performance of the Draeseke Symphonic Andante in May of last year in Kronach, as well as the upcoming (27-28 September 2025) performance of the Gudrun overture in Coburg...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Friday 30 May 2025, 10:51
Thanks, Eric. Do keep us updated if you ever catch wind of a Draeseke performance.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: GoranTch on Saturday 31 May 2025, 16:55
The Violin Concerto was now mentioned several times, and I must confess that I am not even aware of its existence - is there a recording of that piece that you would recommend? "Orchestrated version" -  was it originally composed as a piece for violin and some sort of chamber ensemble?
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: GoranTch on Saturday 31 May 2025, 17:00
Quote from: eschiss1 on Thursday 29 May 2025, 13:05And when the opening of the Classicstoday article is "Felix Draeseke is best known for his monumentally long (and dull) oratorio Christus"...

Wow. Talking about casually dismissing a first class composer in as smug and shallow a way as possible...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Saturday 31 May 2025, 17:32
The Violin Concerto only exists in a violin & piano reduction - the original orchestration is lost, but a replacement was produced about a decade ago by Draeseke expert and pianist, Wolfgang Müller-Steinbach.
Please refer to this webpage: https://www.draeseke.org/news/IDG2009VC/index.htm

Christus is, I am afraid, a monumental bore. The only available recording probably doesn't help, but, on this occasion, I agree with that rather damning verdict.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: eschiss1 on Saturday 31 May 2025, 18:49
Still, if this is what he's best known for (I wasn't aware of it) and not his symphonies (which I still think, pace the spirit of Alan Krueck, also don't have the very best of Draeseke's muse), it makes sure that we get off on the wrong foot from the start. A little like a contemporary article on Beethoven beginning by identifying him with his septet, to give an insufficient analogy (but if an analogy were perfect, it would no longer be an analogy...)
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Saturday 31 May 2025, 18:58
I'd still rescue the Tragica first from the bonfire...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Saturday 31 May 2025, 19:25
Quote from: eschiss1 on Saturday 31 May 2025, 18:49if this is what he's best known for

Meaning? Please elucidate.

To most people, including fans of unsung repertoire, he's not known at all. To others, he's misunderstood because he doesn't fit in to some neat category. In reality, he's a one-ff, a 'harter Nuß', a composer whose idiom often requires a long, hard listen. He'll never be popular. But he deserves far better because his music is of very high quality.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: eschiss1 on Saturday 31 May 2025, 23:25
Please request an elucidation from the author of the article, not from me, as I was clearly quoting it. I assume "best known for" has its usual meaning, known more than for any other thing, which can be a useful relative statement for the least-known of composers, and how well his music is known absolutely is not at issue here at the moment; that said, the author's statement is still asserted, not shown.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Sunday 01 June 2025, 09:29
Apologies, Eric. I had simply lost track of the discussion - my fault. I see that the reference was to Christus.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Ilja on Sunday 01 June 2025, 12:56
Somewhat speculative, but large oratorios such as Christus were very much in demand during the last decades of the 19th century. That changed during the 20th century. From their size and length to the relentless seriousness of their subject matter, they seem to have become regarded as the symbol of all that was wrong with (bourgeois) musical culture. The wake of that rejection took composers with it that were preliminary known for such oratorios: that might explain not only Draeseke's longtime neglect, but also that of someone like Benoit or even Bruch. Even Mendelssohn's large choral works almost disappeared from concert halls.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Sunday 01 June 2025, 13:59
I don't think that Draeseke's reputation was affected much by the failure of Christus, although that probably didn't help. If a masterwork such as his 3rd Symphony didn't make a permanent mark on the musicological map, nothing else was going to change the situation. Of course, he was overtaken by fashion, but then so was Brahms; and Draeseke's music was always a tougher nut to crack, which I think is where the problem lies. You just have to work harder at Draeseke...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: eschiss1 on Sunday 01 June 2025, 14:36
Given how many composers of 20th century British oratorios (Boughton e.g.) were socialists, I'd be careful with generalizations, but...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Ilja on Monday 02 June 2025, 21:13
Something of a confession: I do prefer symphonies 1 & 2 to 3 & 4, and more generally early Draeseke to late Draeseke. It seems to me that his earlier works were imbued with a contagious energy that often went missing later in his career. I can see why people would consider No. 3 the objectively better work, but I honestly don't enjoy it quite as much as its predecessors. Although I also think the work would benefit more than most from a really top-notch recording; the ones that we have are okay, but certainly not stellar.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Monday 02 June 2025, 22:41
I blame dear old Alan Krueck for my enthusiasm. I just wish there were more recordings...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Mark Thomas on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 11:01
There was a time, a decade or so ago, when Draeseke's reputation seemed to be on the ascendent, but interest seems to have faded again. I think Alan's analysis is correct, that it's largely down to his music being a "tough nut to crack". I must confess to finding it so, there aren't many of his works which give immediate pleasure in the way that a more accessible composer's do; I'd cite Raff as a not-so-random comparison. Of course, Draeseke's music at least has the reputation of having an intellectual depth which Raff's lacks, and therein lies it's value, but with the music of so many unsung composers being given an airing in the last few years, not to mention the exposure now available to women and black composers, perhaps it's not surprising that one whose work requires time and thought to appreciate fully has failed to keep the attention of recording labels and buyers. 
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: GoranTch on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 12:23
Quote from: Ilja on Monday 02 June 2025, 21:13Something of a confession: I do prefer symphonies 1 & 2 to 3 & 4, and more generally early Draeseke to late Draeseke. It seems to me that his earlier works were imbued with a contagious energy that often went missing later in his career. I can see why people would consider No. 3 the objectively better work, but I honestly don't enjoy it quite as much as its predecessors. Although I also think the work would benefit more than most from a really top-notch recording; the ones that we have are okay, but certainly not stellar.

Well, this aligns very much with my perception of the symphonies over the years as well, but it is a the same time a strange thing: even though I (heretically) perceive Nos.1 and 2 to be more "rounded" masterpieces then the Tragica, that Scherzo in the 3rd is to me just one of the most mesmerizing Scherzi in all of symphonic music.

Just one among so many rich details in that movement - the way in which that descending flute line is taken over by the celli, as they set in "too early" and overtake it with a kind of brazenly charming mischief... what an incredible compositional moment.     
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: GoranTch on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 12:29
Quote from: Mark Thomas on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 11:01I think Alan's analysis is correct, that it's largely down to his music being a "tough nut to crack". I must confess to finding it so, there aren't many of his works which give immediate pleasure in the way that a more accessible composer's do

Unfortunately, I tend to agree with this. Draeseke sometimes strikes me like a Bruckner who only wrote his 1st, 2nd, 5th and 8th symphonies... (in the sense of having written just the least overtly "beautiful" and accessible works).

One work of his that I know well and I would argue would be among the exceptions is the wonderful Serenade for orchestra.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: John Boyer on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 14:33
Of Draeseke's symphonies I only know the first and the third, and had these been my introduction to the composer I would have never listened to him again. It was enough for me to avoid risking the second and fourth. 

Luckily, my introduction was the quintet for piano, horn, and strings, a winning composition from first note to last that encouraged me to track down more.  His clarinet sonata and cello sonata are also equally engaging works that I would cheerfully recommend to anyone. As for the rest, however, I can work up little enthusiasm.

Why is Draeseke, then, a tough nut to crack in most instances yet so immediately appealing in others?  Or do others find an equal level of difficulty (or engagement) in all his work?
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 15:02
I had an extended email correspondence with Alan Krueck in the last few years of his life and also had the privilege of meeting up with him in London on one occasion. I think his knowledge rubbed off on me. Otherwise, I just enjoyed working on understanding his music; the joy for me is that his compositions are simply unlike anyone else's: he was a fully-fledged New German sympathiser who wrote in the classical forms, unlike Wagner, Liszt, etc. Nobody else of his generation achieved that feat.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: FBerwald on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 15:23
Alan, how would you rate his Piano concerto. It didn't make much of an impression on me the first time. Should I revisit the piece?
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: terry martyn on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 16:15
I was introduced to Draeseke when I stumbled across that ancient 50's LP of his Third.  I'm not sure that was the most favourable introduction to his music.

But the Serenade is a joy,and I am rather fond of his Piano Concerto,particularly the ebullient finale.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 17:17
Quote from: FBerwald on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 15:23Should I revisit the piece?

Definitely - the slow movement's sublime. But avoid the version on MDG with its clattery piano; instead go for Becker on Hyperion:
https://www.prestomusic.com/classical/products/7978558--the-romantic-piano-concerto-47-jadassohn-draeseke
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: John Boyer on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 18:40
Quote from: FBerwald on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 15:23[...H]ow would you rate his Piano concerto. It didn't make much of an impression on me the first time. Should I revisit the piece?

Funny you should ask, because I have been listening to the Piano Concerto quite a bit over the past few weeks.  It's hard to believe that an intellectual composer like Draeseke could write a work so monumentally vulgar (at least in its outer movements) as this. 

From the opening movement, which seems to consist mostly of the piano trying to cram in more scales than the time allotted to play them -- and not much else -- to the finale, which opens with a dead-ringer for the theme from "Mr. Ed" and follows this with a tune straight out of a Victorian music hall, it's a work that wears its bad taste on its sleeve to the same degree that Tchaikovsky wears his heart. 

...And yet...

And yet, we end up with a work SO bad that it's good.  It's the sort of thing that Rubinstein would have written if he had a better command of form and orchestration. Draeseke's Piano Concerto is the very definition of a guilty pleasure, to be experienced in public with embarrassment and in private with mirth.

And in the middle of it all is a slow movement so sublime, as Alan aptly described it, as to seem to be the product of a different composer.  It is, perhaps, Draeseke's most beautiful creation.  When it is over, you'll want to queue it up for an immediate encore because you just don't want to spoil the mood left by the gentle ending.


Yes, by all means revisit the piece, but I would recommend the Tanski/Hanson on MD+G over the Becker/Sanderling on Hyperion.  In terms of sound, the Becker/Sanderling has it all over the Tanski/Hanson. It is clearer and less tubby. We hear more orchestral detail, and Becker's modern Steinway is a better instrument than Tanski's 1925 Blüthner, which sounds improbably fortepiano-ish for a concert grand dating from my grandfather's 29th year. 

But this is an example where the recording with the weaker sound is noticeably the better performance. I don't mean technically, because even here I think Becker/Sanderling play with greater virtuosity, but Tanski and Hanson consistently do a better job of bringing out the best in the music itself. Compare, for example, the final variation of the slow movement: Becker and Sanderling are pretty enough, but Tanski and Hanson play it so delicately -- words like "ethereal" and "gossamer" come to mind -- as to make you sit up in your chair to listen.

Sublime indeed.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Mark Thomas on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 19:10
It's so long since I listened to the Piano Concerto that I have no memory of it, so John's characterisation of it is both intriguing and confounding. I had Draeseke down as a serious, intellectual composer of serious, sometimes even daunting music. So, the slow movement aside, how did he come to compose such a trashy piece? I shall have to listen (to the MDG recording) first thing tomorrow...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 19:21
For the PC, there's always Triendl on Telos, included in his set of the composer's piano music (which I think may now be deleted, sadly). I just find the piano on MDG trying to listen to.
And yes, the first and third movements are among the most extrovert music Draeseke wrote. Very OTT!
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 21:52
Oh, and by the way: Dr Krueck, enthusiast though he was for Draeseke's music, knew that the PC was less than the composer's best. I called it 'garrulous' and I think he would have agreed, although I don't have chapter and verse. I think it has to be enjoyed for what it is: a Lisztian pianistic potboiler with a sublime slow movement.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: eschiss1 on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 22:41
I keep hoping for more recordings specifically of the 2nd and 3rd quartets and the cello sonata and intend to promote them as I can :) ...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Tuesday 03 June 2025, 22:46
BTW, members may be interested in this rather fleeter radio recording of Symphony No.3 with the Nordwestdeutsche Philharmonie under Siegfried Köhler:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=07b-dCI5CyQ&t=780s

Very exciting!
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Mark Thomas on Wednesday 04 June 2025, 12:20
Back, if I may, to the Piano Concerto. John Boyer called the outer movements "vulgar" and that's a very apt description. It's almost as if Draeseke is deliberately parodying the worst excesses of the virtuosic Lisztian concertos of his contemporaries. The bombast, oversized gestures and unsubtle orchestration of these movements are in stark contrast with the central Adagio, which is indeed lovely, but so out of keeping with the rest of the work. It really is the oddest, inexplicable piece.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: terry martyn on Wednesday 04 June 2025, 12:27
Oh dear.

Apart from the Serenade, the finale of the Piano Concerto is one of the few compositions  of Draeseke that I enjoy.

I can sense Lord Charteris's comments about the Duchess of York echoing in my ears.   I must be irredeemably vulgar.it seems.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Wednesday 04 June 2025, 16:58
Quote from: terry martyn on Wednesday 04 June 2025, 12:27the finale of the Piano Concerto is one of the few compositions of Draeseke that I enjoy.

Well, you know that Draeseke's my favourite unsung composer. I take the PC for what it is: an unashamed display piece with a sublime slow movement. Love it!
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: GoranTch on Thursday 05 June 2025, 11:01
Quote from: terry martyn on Wednesday 04 June 2025, 12:27Oh dear.

Apart from the Serenade, the finale of the Piano Concerto is one of the few compositions  of Draeseke that I enjoy.

I can sense Lord Charteris's comments about the Duchess of York echoing in my ears.   I must be irredeemably vulgar.it seems.

Are you familiar with the symphonies? Not necessarily just the Tragica, but Nos.1 and 2?
While certainly not "light" Draeseke, these are masterly works while at the same time being more accessible then the 3rd symphony. The 4th, Comica, is also a wonderful shorter symphony.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: GoranTch on Thursday 05 June 2025, 11:04
Quote from: Mark Thomas on Wednesday 04 June 2025, 12:20Back, if I may, to the Piano Concerto. John Boyer called the outer movements "vulgar" and that's a very apt description. It's almost as if Draeseke is deliberately parodying the worst excesses of the virtuosic Lisztian concertos of his contemporaries. The bombast, oversized gestures and unsubtle orchestration of these movements are in stark contrast with the central Adagio, which is indeed lovely, but so out of keeping with the rest of the work. It really is the oddest, inexplicable piece.

Ok, now I really am intrigued to listen to that one... Don't remember the last time somebody wrote about a piano concerto in terms of it being "the oddest, inexplicable piece"...
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: terry martyn on Thursday 05 June 2025, 11:17
Yes, I have all his symphonies in my collection.  I am going to give numbers 1 and 2 another spin,in the light of your strong recommendation.

I fear that the Third will never be for me,and I listened to Alan's YouTube recommendation the other day. I was shaken,but not stirred.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: John Boyer on Thursday 05 June 2025, 14:10
Quote from: Mark Thomas on Wednesday 04 June 2025, 12:20It's almost as if Draeseke is deliberately parodying the worst excesses of the virtuosic Lisztian concertos of his contemporaries.

Perhaps that's the point.  It would not be the only time a composer took the opportunity to lay out a bit (or a lot) of irony.  The outer movements are so un-Draeseke that maybe he was just playing it for laughs.  What saves it all is that there is so much good humor in it, whereas Liszt's bad imitators are deadly serious in their Sturm-und-Drang excess.  Once you get past the initial bewilderment of the Lisztian bombast, the concerto can be enjoyed for what it is, which is a lot of fun -- Victorian music hall, Mr. Ed, and all.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Mark Thomas on Thursday 05 June 2025, 14:34
QuotePerhaps that's the point.  It would not be the only time a composer took the opportunity to lay out a bit (or a lot) of irony.
It would help, me at least, if I knew that was what Draeseke was doing. Is there evidence in Draeseke's writings or contemporary criticism which might support that idea? The otherwise excellent draeseke.org site only has a not-very-informative 2004 review (https://www.draeseke.org/essays/pianoconcerto.htm) (in German) of the work, and the booklet notes for the Hyperion recording major on Draeseke's apparent debt to Beethoven in the concerto! I no longer have the MDG booklet notes....
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Thursday 05 June 2025, 18:00
I don't think that Draeseke did irony - at least, not until the 4th Symphony. The PC is, I think, a genuine attempt at quasi-Lisztian grandiloquence in which it succeeds triumphantly. I enjoy the work for what it is, a one-off display piece: Draeseke, after all, was a one-off composer. There's nobody quite like him.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: John Boyer on Thursday 05 June 2025, 20:25
Quote from: Mark Thomas on Thursday 05 June 2025, 14:34I no longer have the MDG booklet notes....

According to Matthias Schaefers's notes, a review of the first performance described the concerto as "intended primarily for the display of virtuoso brilliance on the part of the interpreter of the piano part".  Schaefers goes on to say that during the compositional process Draeseke told the dedicatee that he

was disturbed by the passage work when it came to the design of the overall structure of the work.  As a result, for the time being he had made a purely symphonic design and planned to add the passage work in later on. In the outer movements [...], however, passage work and symphonic design sometimes appear as extremes between which no mediation at all seems to be intended.  [...T]he beginning of the first movement is already indicative of what is to follow.  The orchestra intones the main theme [...] but is interrupted by rushing scales and broken chords in the abrupt interventions of the the piano.  It is only after the third entry of the orchestra that the piano part takes on motivic trenchancy -- and this only for a short time.  [...T]he sections in the further course of the outer movements in which the piano is included in the motivic process are relatively short. 

The quality of the thematic material aside, Schaefers is suggesting that the piano part in the outer movements is worked in almost as an afterthought.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Thursday 05 June 2025, 20:33
Quote from: John Boyer on Thursday 05 June 2025, 20:25described the concerto as "intended primarily for the display of virtuoso brilliance on the part of the interpreter of the piano part".

Thanks, John. And for the remainder of this fascinating review.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Mark Thomas on Thursday 05 June 2025, 21:02
Thanks, John. That all seems to make sense.
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Wheesht on Friday 06 June 2025, 14:15
A Swiss performance of the symphonic poem "Der Thuner See" in Thun in 1999 was apparently only the second time the piece had ever been performed.
The CD (or download) is still available from the Stadtorchester Thun, but the ordering information on draeseke.org is no longer up-to-date. This is the current contact information:
Thuner Stadtorchester
3600 Thun
Switzerland
mail@thunerstadtorchester.ch or info@thunerstadtorchester.ch

The CD is CHF 15.00 plus p&p, the download of the CD is CH 12.00 including a pdf of the booklet, the download of just the Draeseke piece is CH 5.00 (with booklet pdf).

A member of the Internationale Draeseke Gesellschaft has combined "Der Thuner See" with images of Lake Thun and surroundings in this film (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Up2mHC07ci4&pp=ygUZRHJhZXNla2UgLSBEZXIgVGh1bmVyIFNlZQ==).
Title: Re: Felix Draeseke's other Symphonies
Post by: Alan Howe on Friday 06 June 2025, 17:10
Thanks for all this information. This is prime late Draeseke in quite an advanced idiom, demonstrating once again his individuality as a composer. The work really needs a real-world recording by a top orchestra, but nobody seems interested.